Moth Traps: Compared

Moth Traps_ Compared

Moth Traps: Compared

Moths love to come out when the weather warms. Whether it be a Closet Moth or a Pantry Moth, they are in search of something to eat, so they can begin the process of breeding. To aid you in dealing with a moth infestation we have gathered a list of the best moth traps compared for 2019.

Type Of Moths

Pantry Moths

The Pantry Moth, also known as the Indian Meal Moth, is the most common among the pantry pests. The feed on flour, uncooked beans and rice, cereal, and dog food.

Clothes Moths

Webbing Moths and Casemaking Moths are two types of Clothes Moths. They feed off fabric like wool, silk, and leather. They live in closets, basements, and attics.

Carpet Moths

The Carpet Moth is also known as the Tapestry Moth is small. Larvae feed on clothing, fur, bird nests, and carpet.

Gypsy Moths

The Gypsy Moth primarily lives in the northeastern region of the United States. Larvae feed on various types of vegetation. Older larvae feed on different types of hardwood. They rarely infiltrate a home; the gypsy moth traps are fairly large and are attached to trees where their presence has been determined.

Signs Of Moth Activity

Each species of moth will leave telltale signs of their presence. These can include:
Damage to the items they are feeding on: clothing, carpets, food contamination.
Active larvae present: From a tiny ⅝” Pantry moth to a 2-inch Gypsy Moth.
Fecal matter or casing: Pinhead dots and shedding from the larvae of full-grown moth.
Adult Moth sighting: Seeing the actual moth itself. If you see one, there are more.

How Do Moth Traps Work?

There are a wide variety of moth traps on the market. Some contain pesticides, while others use chemical free attractants for the eco-friendly minded. In either case, the job of a moth trap is to attract the moth and trap it.

Types Of Moth Traps

Wax Moth Traps

Not mentioned above as Wax Moths are primarily an issue for those who keep bees. Wax Moths feed on beeswax. Wax Moth traps are commonly insecticide based. While they can handle the infestation, they are harmful to humans and require special handling.

Light Moth Traps

Moths are attracted to light. Light traps that are designed to attract and dispose of these pests, i.e. bug zappers. However, this solution is primarily used outdoors, and they often need cleaning.


Mothballs can be used in conjunction with clothes moth traps. They repel moths as they release a chemical odor that is harmful to moths. While effective, these can have harmful effects on humans when used for a long duration.

Pheromone Moth Traps

Pheromone moth traps also use odor. However, instead of repelling, they attract moths. They become stuck through a glue strip for later disposal. This solution can be useful, but are often unsightly, odorous, and are unpleasant to dispose of if one has a disgust concerning moths.

Wafer Moth Traps

A wafer moth trap contains pheromones, but not in a glue or power. The wafer attracts to the glue trap. As with most traps, they need disposal after they are full, or the pheromone wafer loses its attracting ability.

Brands Of Moth Traps

All the brands below are pheromone moth traps. They are among the best moth traps you can buy. One commonality they share is they all generally last for three months. For the purpose of this moth traps compared review, we line up comparable Pantry Moth glue traps that use pheromone as an attractant.

Terro Moth Traps

These pantry moth traps are on the large size, 4.875″ x 11.0″. They are triangular and are placed on a shelf. They sell as a 2 pack for $8.99. That averages to $4.50 each.

Catchmaster Moth Traps

This pheromone moth trap is 2” x 5.25”. They are triangular and rest on a shelf. They sell for $7.98 for two moth traps Home Depot. That is about $4.00 per trap.

Safer Moth Traps

This moth trap is 5.5” x 4”. It is also triangular and is laid on a shelf. They sell as a pack of 2 for $9.99. This price point makes it the most expensive at $5.00 per trap.

Dr. Killigan’s Moth Traps

Dr. Killigan’s Pantry Moth traps ™ are 5” x 4.5” inches. They are triangular and can be placed on a shelf. However, these traps do have the ability to be hung. They sell in a pack of 6 for $14.97. This is the best value with each trap costing $2.50.

How The Best Moth Traps Differ

All four moth traps reviewed generally function the same. There are a few differences that will make all the difference when it comes to the aesthetics of how to get rid of moths.

Moth Trap Appearance

One of the first things people notice about Dr. Killigan’s, Inc. ™ products is: “Dr. Killigan’s line of products are attractive to the eye. With a modern and colorful design that fits into the décor of your kitchen, pantry, laundry room, or closet, you are never sickened by the appearance of a pest control device.”

Moth Trap Effectiveness

Most pheromone moth traps use a combination of a pheromone wafer and a glue strip. The wafers are separate and must be placed onto the glue strip when assembled. Dr. Killigan’s Moth Traps ™ do not require wafers. The pheromone is mixed into the glue. There is no fiddling to opening the pheromone package while trying not to touch the glue while placing the wafer into the trap.

Moth Trap Cost

As stated above, the best cost by far is Dr. Killigan’s Premium Moth Traps ™ . Competitors often sell their product in a 2 pack, Dr. Killigan’s, Inc. ™ packages contain 6 traps. The end cost is half of the Safer Moth Trap ™.

Dr Killigan’s, Inc. ™ comes out on top based on quality, effectiveness, and appearance. They also offer top notch customer service for those with questions about the differences in products.

Dr. Killigan’s, Inc. ™ Tops The Moth Traps Compared

All Dr. Killigan’s, Inc. ™ products are 100% safe, non-toxic, and bring ‘classy’ back into the pest control space. The traps are also made with recycled paper and are considered a Green Product, another positive for the eco-minded.

While this “moth traps compared” review covers pantry moths, you may be dealing with a different type of moth. Be sure that you are searching for the correct type of moth to provide the best solution for the needs in your home. Pantry Moth Traps for food/pantry, to attract the Indian Meal Moth. Clothing Moth Traps, for the Casing or Webbing Moth. Just as Dr. Killigan’s ™ has the best pantry moth traps, they also sell a top of the line product to help protect your wool, silks and furs: Clothing Moth Traps. As always, Dr. Killigan will be Killing Them Softly ™ .

Get Pantry Traps Now

Related Content: