Which is worse? Unmasking the differences between silverfish and earwigs


Ah, the question that stirs unease in even the most stoic homeowner: silverfish or earwigs, which is the greater fiend? Both unwelcome guests in our domestic sanctuaries, both capable of sending shivers down spines and chills across floorboards. Yet, to truly vanquish these nocturnal nuisances, we must first understand their distinctions, their unique brand of mischief, and the appropriate strategies for their dismissal.


Dining preferences: A tale of two pests

Our first point of inquiry concerns their culinary cravings. The silverfish, a creature of refined (if destructive) taste, favors starchy delights. Books with their crisp pages, wallpaper imbued with paste, and even fabrics woven with starches - all become delectable fodder for these silver specters. 

Earwigs, on the other hand, exhibit a broader palate. While not averse to the occasional starchy snack, they also relish decaying organic matter, tender shoots of houseplants and even their fellow arthropods, earning them the unsavory moniker "pincher bug."

Morphology makes a difference: Distinguishing features

Indeed, both silverfish and earwigs prefer the hushed hours of darkness and revel in navigating the hidden corridors beneath our baseboards. However, fear not, for a keen eye can readily discern these nocturnal nuisances, even in the dimmest light. The silverfish, a creature aptly named for its shimmering scales, slithers gracefully like a slender, wingless phantom, adorned with three delicate, tail-like appendages and possessing remarkably long antennae that twitch and probe its surroundings. 


Its earwig counterpart, however, presents a broader, flatter silhouette, its most striking feature being the formidable pincers adorning its rear. While these fearsome-looking appendages may cause alarm, rest assured that they pose little threat to human skin. Additionally, earwigs boast a pair of short, membranous wings tucked beneath their abdomen, though their airborne aspirations rarely translate into sustained flight. 

Remember, knowledge is our first line of defense against even the most unsettling of houseguests. By understanding their distinct appearances, we can effectively identify and address their unwelcome presence.

Habitat havens: Where they lurk and hide

Both silverfish and earwigs favor moisture and darkness. Bathrooms, basements, attics, and laundry rooms become their nocturnal playgrounds. Silverfish, with their flattened bodies, excel at squeezing beneath floorboards and into the narrow crevasses of bookshelves. Earwigs, meanwhile, prefer the damp comfort of crawl spaces and beneath decaying mulch piles.

Destructive delights: The damage they inflict

Ah, the unfortunate side effects of our nocturnal guests. While it's true that neither silverfish nor earwigs possess the means to directly bite or sting us humans, their presence can nonetheless bring a host of unwelcome consequences. 

The silverfish, with its insatiable hunger for starchy delights, can leave a trail of destruction in its wake, devouring prized books, marring precious wallpapers and nibbling away at other cherished possessions, including fabrics woven with starches. Their earwig counterparts, meanwhile, may not directly harm us, but their nocturnal symphony of scurrying and clicking pincers can disrupt the peaceful slumber we all deserve. 


Additionally, while not as voracious as silverfish, earwigs can also damage fabrics and wallpapers, particularly if they are damp or left undisturbed for extended periods. In the unfortunate case of individuals with sensitivities, both pests can trigger allergic reactions, adding another layer of discomfort to their unwelcome presence. 

Remember, friends, even minor infestations can lead to substantial disruptions, not to mention the emotional distress of finding one's possessions under siege. Let us not underestimate the potential impact of these seemingly small creatures. Instead, let us arm ourselves with knowledge and effective solutions to restore peace and tranquility to our domestic sanctuaries.

Who claims the throne of torment?

To declare a singular "worse" pest is a fruitless endeavor. Ultimately, the severity of the infestation and the individual's personal squeamishness will determine which creature elicits greater distaste. While silverfish pose a significant threat to valued possessions, earwigs' pincers, though alarming in appearance, rarely cause harm. Each warrants swift and effective eradication.

The great divide: A summary of silverfish and earwig distinctions

To solidify our understanding of these nocturnal nuisances, let us summarize their key differences:


  • Silverfish: Primarily starchy materials like books, wallpaper and fabrics.
  • Earwigs: More diverse, including decaying organic matter, plant shoots and other insects.


  • Silverfish: Slender, wingless, metallic silver with three long tail-like appendages.
  • Earwigs: Broader, flatter, brownish with prominent pincers at the rear of their abdomen.
  • Silverfish: Moist, dark areas like bathrooms, basements and attics, often hidden in crevices.
  • Earwigs: Similar preferences, but also favor damp spaces like crawl spaces and under mulch.


  • Silverfish: Destruction of starchy materials and paper goods.
  • Earwigs: Potential damage to plants and nuisance noise, rarely pose direct harm to humans.

The arsenal of Dr. Killigan: Banishing both bugs

Dr. Killigan's arsenal boasts two powerful tools for eliminating these unwelcome guests, both formulated with safety in mind when used as directed:insect-spray-and-powderinsect-spray-and-powderinsect-spray-and-powder

  • Dust to Dust Non-Toxic Insect Powder: Our plant-powered champion creates a persistent, protective barrier on surfaces. Its gentle yet effective formula, utilizing micro-sized particles and essential oils, disrupts their exoskeletons and nervous systems, leading to dehydration and ultimately, demise. Think of it as a microscopic obstacle course and aromatic confusion, all working together to keep your home pest-free while ensuring the safety of your family pets and children when used as directed.
  • Six Feet Under Non-Toxic Insect Spray: For those immediate encounters with scuttling silverfish or unwelcome earwigs, Six Feet Under offers a targeted "kill-on-contact" solution. This spray acts quickly and effectively, ensuring that pesky invaders become six feet under (figuratively, of course). 

Remember, combating pests effectively requires a holistic approach. Alongside utilizing Dr. Killigan's solutions, consider addressing potential attractants in your home:

  • Moisture control: Fix leaky faucets, repair damp basements and ensure proper ventilation in bathrooms and laundry rooms.
  • Eliminate harborage areas: Declutter, vacuum regularly and store belongings in sealed containers to minimize hiding places.
  • Seal entry points: Check for cracks around windows, doors and pipes, and seal them to prevent future invasions.

By combining Dr. Killigan's targeted solutions with preventative measures, you can create a home environment that is both comfortable for you and inhospitable to unwanted guests, all while prioritizing the safety of your family and furry friends. So, banish the bugs, reclaim your peace of mind, and let Dr. Killigan be your trusted guide in this noble quest for a pest-free haven.

Reading next

Do all bees and wasps sting, and when should you worry?

Get into the nitty-gritty on insects & arachnids

View all

How long can spiders live without food?

Explore the surprising endurance of spiders and uncover how these resilient creatures survive for weeks without food.


3 ways to get rid of boxelder bugs (and 4 ways to prevent them)

Discover effective methods to eliminate and prevent boxelder bugs. Learn about their habits, what attracts them and how you can keep your home bug-free.


Are wasps dangerous? Unveiling 5 reasons to coexist carefully

Explore the true nature of wasp dangers and learn five reasons why careful coexistence with social wasps is crucial for our safety and their survival.

Read all about our unique ingredients

View all

Putting customers first: The power of full disclosure from Dr. Killigan's

Discover the power of full disclosure at Dr. Killigan's and how our transparency puts you in control of your pest solutions.


What makes an ant killer pet-safe?

Navigating the challenge of ant infestations while ensuring the safety of our pets is crucial. Learn the key features of pet-safe ant sprays and powders.  


Home preparation for travel & maintaining a pest-free haven

Travel with ease using Dr. Killigan's home preparation guide. Discover deep cleaning strategies and download our free house cleaning checklist for a pest-free return.